|
|
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Lucinda Bateman MD
Click here
for printable copy
The following discussion is based on published CFS
research combined with my own experience and study of CFS,
and should be considered a working hypothesis:
CFS is a condition defined by
the presence of chronic fatigue that results in
significantly decreased function, that is of definite onset
(not lifelong), not readily explained by an identifiable
underlying medical or mental health condition, and usually
accompanied by some or all of the following symptoms:
impairment of memory or concentration, headaches, muscle or
joint pain, unrefreshing sleep, sore throats, tender lymph
nodes and post exertional flare of symptoms. See discussion
of Case Definitions at the end of the handout.
CFS may occur in a
"genetically predisposed" individual, who is often "run
down" by ordinary or unusual "life stressors," and may start
with a "flu syndrome" that seems to leave chronic symptoms
and fatigue rather than resolving in a normal fashion.
Epidemiologic studies suggest that a large number of people
who meet criteria for CFS may not have distinct flu-like
onset of symptoms, and that symptoms meeting CFS most common
in lower socioeconomic groups and minorities.
The exact cause of CFS is
unknown. No single infection has been proven a primary cause
of CFS, although many viral and atypical pathogens have been
studied as possible primary or secondary co-factors.
Research suggests that patients with CFS have mildly
suppressed Natural Killer cell activity and cell mediated
immunity (probably abnormal CD4 activation of CD8 viral
killing), with a shift toward upregulated B-cell mediated
immunity. In the later stages of illness patients have more
B-cell derived illness such as "allergy" symptoms,
upregulated antibody systems (antithyroid and antinuclear
antibodies), and pro-inflammatory cytokine release. Flow
cytometry studies of lymph node biopsy show chronically
activated T-cells (compared to peripheral blood) consistent
with this chronically up-regulated state. It is not clear if
recurrent or latent virus(s) are currently present and
driving the system, if it is chronically "immune" driven, or
if there are other involved processes extrinsic to the
immune pathways.
Many patients have
significant autonomic nervous system dysfunction, manifest
by orthostatic intolerance or postural orthostatic
tachycardia (POTS), sweating or temperature intolerance,
Sicca syndrome (dry eyes and mouth), irritable bowel and
gastric reflux, bladder spasm, etc. Neurocognitive and
neuropsychological symptoms are often prominent, and flare
as the symptom complex flares. Abnormal sleep patterns with
alpha intrusion, abnormal Stage III, IV and REM phases are
often present. In addition, Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal
(HPA) axis dysfunction has been documented as low CRH,
cortisol, and perhaps a contribution to the marked
orthostatic intolerance or Neurally Mediated Hypotension
(NMH) documented on Tilt Table testing. Numerous forms of
brain imaging have demonstrated regional flow abnormalities
(SPECT), areas of hypometabolism (PET), and areas of
nonspecific demyelination or infarct (MRI). In addition
these areas of research, genetic studies underway in twins
and affected families show a familial predisposition to
developing CFS.
Since the cause of CFS is
still unknown, the best general treatments at
this point for the illness complex and associated symptoms
are to:
Additional recommendations apply on an
individual basis:
---If primary or secondary
viral or bacterial infection or known immune
dysfunction (allergies and asthma) can be identified,
treating the condition might reduce CFS symptoms.
---If orthostatic
intolerance is prominent, it may respond partially to
standard interventions such as oral fluids (2 liters of
water daily), sodium (2–4 gms per day) and electrolyte
supplementation, fludrocortisone (Florinef) 0.1-0.2 mg
daily, a trial of midodrine (ProAmatine) 2.5-10 mg 3 to 4
times a day while up and active (i.e. not while sleeping or
resting).
—Replacing identifiable
hormone deficiencies can be useful in modulating
symptoms, but should be monitored carefully due to the known
potential side effects associated with each hormone.
---Stimulants and Provigil
are occasionally helpful, but should be used cautiously
because of impact on sleep, anxiety, and the tendency to
over exert instead of pace appropriately.
---Anti-depressant,
anti-anxiety and anti-convulsant medications can be
helpful for some aspects of the syndrome independent of
affect on mood.
EVERY prominent or focal symptom
should be investigated and treated in a
supportive manner,
both at onset and at appropriate intervals
while ill.
The 1988 (CDC or Holmes)
CFS Case Definition (or "Working Case Definition of CFS")
requires that patients meet the Major Criteria
of new onset fatigue and fatigability that does not
resolve with rest, that causes at least a 50% reduction in
activity, for at least 6 months, and the exclusion of
all other illnesses that can cause fatigue, including
existing psychiatric illness, and Minor Criteria of >
6 month duration, including at least 6 of 8 symptoms
(fever, sore throat, painful lymph nodes, general
weakness, prolonged fatigue after exercise, headaches,
arthralgia, sleep disturbance, neuropsychological
complaints, and sudden onset of symptoms complex) and
2 signs (low grade fever, non-exudative pharyngitis,
and palpable or tender lymph nodes).
The 1994 "Revised Case
Definition of CFS" (Annals of Internal Medicine, December
1994, Fukuda) is reached after a process of excluding
other illnesses and is defined as: clinically evaluated,
unexplained persistent or relapsing chronic fatigue of > 6
month duration, not otherwise explained by another known
medical or psychiatric condition (, of new or definite
onset, not the result of ongoing exertion, not
substantially alleviated by rest, and that results in
substantial reduction in previous levels of function; plus
concurrent presence of (at least 4): impairment in
short term memory or concentration, muscle pain, joint pain,
headaches of a new pattern or severity, unrefreshing sleep,
sore throat, tender cervical or axillary lymph nodes, and
post exertional malaise. Specific exclusions include: an
ongoing medical illness that can obviously cause such
fatigue, psychiatric illness psychotic features, dementia,
anorexia or bulimia, alcohol or other substance abuse, and
obesity defined as a Body Mass Index (BMI) > 45.
No Case Definition was
intended to exclude patients from the diagnosis, but
rather to help identify and treat underlying problems, and
to define a better, more homogeneous, "CFS" group for
research purposes. The larger populations of patients with
chronic fatigue, exertion intolerance, ill defined pain,
insomnia, cognitive dysfunction and other symptoms probably
have a number of underlying problems that include atypical
presentation of known diseases, combined processes,
psychological factors, and disease processes we still poorly
understand.
Several other Case
Definitions are evolving, including the "Canadian Case
Definition" formulated by a panel of experts from Canada
and the US, that is generally accepted as a better clinical
tool than the 1988 and 1994 versions. (This is published as
"Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome:
Clinical Working Case Definition, Diagnostic and Treatment
Protocols" in the Journal of CFS; Vol.11, No 1, 2003.) The
CDC is working on a new case definition based on further
study of CFS patients identified in their epidemiological
study in Wichita, Kansas.
Mounting research in the last
10 years has clearly shown that in spite of their
weaknesses, all of the CFS Case Definitions successfully
separate a group of afflicted and often disabled patients
who do not simply have a mood disorder, poor motivation or
any other readily identifiable problem. These patients
deserve support and medical attention both clinically and on
a research basis until more data is forthcoming. Most
likely, the CFS Case Definitions encompass a group made of
up more than one cause and combination of causes. More work
is needed to develop objective markers that will delineate
subgroups of CFS and related conditions such as fibromyalgia
syndrome, multiple chemical sensitivity syndrome, and
others.
There is discussion about
what else to call this complex and often disabling
condition, which is arguably not well served by the term
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. In Europe and Canada, the term
Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) was used long before the CDC
coined the term "CFS" in the mid 1980's. Patient advocates
in the U.S. often prefer the term "CFIDS" (Chronic Fatigue
Immune Dysfunction Syndrome), a synonym for CFS. Much debate
within the CFS community has focused on when and
what to better name the condition. At this point, most
researchers and clinicians hope that emerging information
regarding pathophysiology will help resolve the conflicts.
Updated 10/04
|